Free, free, set them free? Are programmes effective that allow job centres considerable freedom to choose the exact design?

Abstract

"Active labour market programmes are expected to be quite effective if job centres have a substantial degree of freedom to deliver tailor‐made individual services. For Germany, we studied the effectiveness of Schemes for Activation and Integration (SAI), which were introduced in 2009 to grant such freedoms to implement short training and private placement services. We estimated SAI participation effects on welfare recipients’ earnings and employment rate using propensity score matching and rich administrative data. We distinguished between participation in in‐firm training or training in other settings, and considered effect heterogeneity by gender, region and non‐employment duration. Participation substantially improved the participants’ earnings and employment rate, in‐firm training more so than training in other settings. Our employment effect estimates were not considerably larger than those previously found for comparable pre‐reform programmes. A lack of experience with SAI and a still inadequate client focus in the period studied might explain this." (Author's Abstract, IAB-Doku)

Cite article

Harrer, T., Moczall, A. & Wolff, J. (2020): Free, free, set them free? Are programmes effective that allow job centres considerable freedom to choose the exact design? In: International journal of social welfare, Vol. 29, No. 2, p. 154-167. DOI:10.1111/ijsw.12405